A discussion about whether we can be able to generalize from empirical data in political research

In sciences that involve the study of humans, it is essential to identify those aspects of measurement error that attenuate the estimation of the relationships of interest e. Difficulties in making repeated observations on cohorts depend on the length of time of the study.

External validity

When it is impossible to relate cases of a disease to a population, perhaps because the cases were ascertained through a hospital with an undefined catchment area, proportional morbidity rates may be used. Generalities are required for communication. A site devoted to IQ testing summarized: If a positive family history is associated with development of schizophrenia, then more cases would occur in the first group than in the second group.

Thus, external and ecological validity are independent — a study may possess external validity but not ecological validity, and vice versa. Well-known research designs e. New theories about the periodicity of the ice ages, similarly, were informed by multiple methods e.

In selecting a population for study, the research question or purpose of the study will suggest a suitable definition of the population to be studied, in terms of location and restriction to a particular age group, sex or occupation. For such long duration investigations, it is wise to select study cohorts that are firstly, not likely to migrate, cooperative and likely to be so throughout the duration of the study, and most importantly, easily accessible to the investigator so that the expense and efforts are kept within reasonable limits.

This may not be a limitation when generalization of results is not intended. In the social sciences and education, such quantitative measures are sometimes difficult to generate; in any case, a statement about the nature and estimated magnitude of error must be made in order to signal the level of certainty with which conclusions have been drawn.

A statistical population need not consist only of people. We generalize to better understand the world Dogs are furry mammals that have four legs and a tail. The effects shown in the treatment averages may not generalize to any subgroup.

On balance, generalizations about political ideologies are true

In developing countries, listings of all persons living in an area are not usually available. When non-random samples are representative compare the socio-demographic characteristics of the sample subjects with the target populationgeneralization may be possible. A systematic sample can be drawn from a queue of people or from patients ordered according to the time of their attendance at a clinic.

The integration and interaction of multiple disciplinary perspectives—with their varying methods—often accounts for scientific progress Wilson, ; this is evident, for example, in the advances in understanding early reading skills described in Chapter 2.

For example, suppose we are studying malaria in a population. They criticize the lack of ecological validity in many laboratory-based studies with a focus on artificially controlled and constricted environments. Because of this feasibility, a systematic sample may have some advantage over a simple random sample.

The ultimate decision on whether the results of a particular study can be generalized to a larger population depends on this understanding. In the physical and life sciences, quantitative estimates of the error associated with conclusions are often computed and reported.

To undertake a separate exercise of listing the population for the study may be time consuming and tedious. Claims to knowledge vary substantially according to the strength of the research design, theory, and control of extraneous variables and by systematically ruling out possible alternative explanations.

Use of the word population in epidemiological research does not correspond always with its demographic meaning of an entire group of people living within certain geographic or political boundaries.

Scientific Research in Education. If we avoid generalities we understand nothing. There are at last three ways to construct a generality: If more than a small proportion of persons in the cohort cannot be traced loss to follow-up or attritionthe findings will be biased, in case these persons differ significantly from those remaining in the study.

Will the research develop, extend, modify, or test a hypothesis? We do not know to what extent the study sample and population of Delhi is typical of the larger population — that of the whole country — to which it belongs.can be found across the full range of scientific inquiry.

Throughout this chapter we provide examples from a variety of domains—in political science, geophysics, and. Start studying HDFS Exam 1. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.

Scientific research is empirical 2) Scientific research is objective 3) Scientific research is public and develops a research study to determine whether the article's ideas are correct. This study can be classified as. collect data only on what can actually be observed; hence, subjective and intangible For your own research project, consider whether you intend to adopt an inductive approach, we can select between them.

Looking for other ways to read this?

As Crotty () demonstrates, one of the problems. Highlight the importance of your study and how it may be able to contribute to and/or help fill existing gaps in the field.

Statistics without tears: Populations and samples

additional data could have revealed]. The discussion section should end with a concise summary of the principal implications of the findings regardless of significance. Recommendations for further research can be. Start studying Research Methods. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.

What is Generalization?

The degree to which we can generalize our findings to a wider population or other cases and contexts. -The main differences between quantitative and qualitative research consist in respect to data sample, data collection. Generalization Essay Examples. 2 total results. A Discussion About Whether We Can Be Able to Generalize from Empirical Data in Political Research.

2, words. 6 pages. A Case Study on the Concept of Cosmetic Psychopharmacology and the Controversies Surrounding the Substance Abuse.

A discussion about whether we can be able to generalize from empirical data in political research
Rated 4/5 based on 7 review