To what extent is the turner thesis valid

Smart people come up with them and they check if their answers are right compared to the scientfic answer. They emphasized the values of individualism, empiricism, simplicity, equality, courage, discovery, independence, and naturalism in the service of democratic access, human rights, ecological balance, and the resolution of social, economic, and political issues.

Rebelling against this view, Turner argued instead that Europeans had been transformed by the process of settling the American continent and that what was unique about the United States was its frontier history.

Mode inargued that churches adapted to the characteristics of the frontier, creating new denominations such as the Mormonsthe Church of Christthe Disciples of Christand the Cumberland Presbyterians.

The winner of an oratorical medal as an undergraduate, he also was a gifted and active public speaker. All of his girls grew up successful and educated. Awarded his doctorate inhe was one of the first historians professionally trained in the United States rather than Europe.

Each new territory that was organized-there were 31in all-required a frame of government; this was drafted by relatively poor recent arrivals or by a minority of tipper-class leaders, all of whom were committed to democratic ideals through their frontier community experiences.

But among those conditions none has bulked larger than the operation of the frontier process. Americans today reflect their background in placing the "intellectual" well below the "practical businessman" in their scale of heroes. America 39;s Frontier Heritagean analysis of Turner 39;s theories in nbsp; PBS — THE WEST — Frederick Jackson Turner cogently articulated this idea in quot;The Significance of the Frontier in American Turner offered his frontier thesis as both an analysis of the past and a nbsp; criticism of the frontier thesis American Disasters accomplishes his goal of shining bright light on the memory of the out some of the highest and most vitalizing activities of the general government.

Democracy, according to anti-Turnerians, was well advanced in" Europe and was transported to America on the Susan Constant and the Mayflower, within this country democratic practices have multiplied most rapidly as a result of eastern lower-class pressures and have only been imitated in the West.

Even though they may be sheeplike in following the decrees of social arbiters or fashion dictators, Americans today, like their pioneer ancestors, dislike governmental interference in their affairs- "Rugged individualism" did not originate on the, frontier any more than democracy or nationalism did, but each concept was deepened and sharpened by frontier conditions.

Born in Portage, Wisconsin, in of pioneer parents from upper New York state, he was reared in a land fringed by the interminable forest and still stamped with the mark of youth.

This was especially the case with the early town builders. Morgan that the extension of American authority abroad, either through territorial acquisitions or economic penetration, would be good for both business and democracy. The anti-intellectualism and materialism which are national traits can also be traced to the frontier experience.

Corporate investors headquartered in New York laid the railroads; government troops defeated Indian nations who refused to get out of the way of manifest destiny; even the cowboys, enshrined in popular mythology as rugged loners, were generally low-level employees of sometimes foreign-owned cattle corporations.

In broad terms, the further west, the more American the community. The Senior thesis can also be seen as a masters thesis. To Turner this explanation was unsatisfactory.

Valid Interpretation of American History? Urban historian Richard C. Would you like to merge this question into it? Limits to Growth was right. In the boisterous western borderlands, book learning and intellectual speculation were suspect among those dedicated to the material tasks necessary to subdue a continent.

This is true even of one of his statements that has been more vigorously disputed than any other: He is known Nicaraguan Journey ; Imaginary Homelands: The abandonment of cultural baggage during the migrations, the borrowings from the many cultures represented in each pioneer settlement, the deviations natural in separate evolutions, and the impact of the environment all played their parts in creating a unique social organism similar to but differing from those in the East.

As the newcomers moved backward along the scale of civilization, the habits and customs of their traditional cultures were forgotten. Successive generations moved further inland, shifting the lines of settlement and wilderness, but preserving the essential tension between the two.

If a safety valve did exist at that time, it was a rural safety valve, drawing off surplus farm labor and thus lessening agrarian discontent among the Granger and Populist eras.


He writes how the frontier drove American history and why America is what it is today. In actuality, however, the settlement of the West had depended, to a surprising degree, on intervention by the federal government.

For many women, Asians, Mexicans who suddenly found themselves residents of the United States, and, of course, Indians, the West was no promised land.

Limerick points out that Kennedy assumed that "the campaigns of the Old Frontier had been successful, and morally justified. It is a thesis that has been respected in the historical circle for many years.

It also expresses your opinion or how you feel about the subject. He then marries and has three children, and is able to send his girls to school.

Frederick Jackson Turner

Turner offered his frontier thesis as both an analysis of the past and a warning about the future. Australia, as a result, developed an urban civilization.

Moreover, these revisionist scholars argue, for many places the West has not been the land of freedom and opportunity that both Turnerian history and popular mythology would have us believe. The frontier thesis is one of the most influential documents on the American west today.

It also provided land grants that funded railroad building, and, in the 20th century, support for dams and other waterworks. Historians have noted that John F.Apr 17,  · Which Criticism Of The Turner Thesis Seems Most Valid Some Thoughts on Frederick Jackson Turner and the Frontier Dr One of the most discussed ideas in American history, Frederick Jackson's Frontier Thesis continues to cause controversy and debates today.

in the broadest sense, they remain valid because the frontier experience in the Ohio Valley. Turner Thesis () Frederick Jackson Turner’s Frontier Thesis History professor, Univ. of Wisconsin Thesis: frontier experience and westward expansion had stimulated individualism, nationalism, and democracy Suggested “frontier” had alleviated social and economic problems of an industrial society.

Frederick Jackson Turner, (born November 14,Portage, Wisconsin, U.S.—died March 14,San Marino, California), American historian best known for the “frontier thesis.” The single most influential interpretation of the American past, it proposed that the distinctiveness of the United.

Opposition to the Turner Thesis. Inin "The Frontier and American Institutions: A Criticism of the Turner Thesis," Professor George Wilson Pierson debated the validity of the Turner thesis, stating that many factors influenced American culture besides the looming frontier.

Although he respected Turner, Pierson strongly argues his point by looking beyond the frontier and acknowledging other factors in Author: Frederick Jackson Turner.

Frederick Jackson Turner ___Frederick Jackson Turner___ The Significance of the Frontier in American History A paper read at the meeting of the American Historical Association In the discussion of its extent, its westward movement, etc., it can not, therefore, any longer have a.

Is it still a valid key to the meaning of American history? Turner's own background provides a clue to the answer. Born in Portage, Wisconsin, in of pioneer parents from upper New York state, he was reared in a land fringed by the interminable forest and still stamped with the mark of youth.

To what extent is the turner thesis valid
Rated 4/5 based on 91 review